Not having a lot of luck with Feather RP2040

I grabbed the Adafruit Feather board with USB-A hoping to get some of my old gamepads working as keyboard inputs. I loaded the remapper_feather.uf2 as instructed. The Gravis Gamepad Pro does not register on the board (no orange light, no signals on the monitor) and two other gamepads (generic with analog sticks and a Saitek P880) work for about 30 seconds and then the little light goes off and the board is locked up, requiring a reset. Any idea why these won’t work?